Question 1

What is the Madison BBQ Saloon?

Accepted Answer

Madison is Pink Heifer's fast casual sister location to the Monticello Mothership. It is built for quick pickup, delivery, lunch, late night meals, and State Street energy.

Question 2

Is Madison the same quality as Monticello?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Madison has a smaller, more focused menu, but the quality, recipes, smokehouse standards, and consistency are the exact same standard guests expect from Monticello.

Question 3

Where does the barbecue come from?

Accepted Answer

Both locations receive product from one central Pink Heifer smokehouse. Product is prepared there and delivered fresh every morning to Madison and Monticello, helping keep the quality consistent from location to location.

Question 4

What is different about the Madison menu?

Accepted Answer

Madison offers a smaller menu designed for fast casual service, while keeping the Pink Heifer favorites guests come for, including USDA Prime brisket, premium pulled pork, juicy smoked chicken, signature Wagon Rolls, sandwiches, platters, mac bowls, salads, and scratch made sides.

Question 5

How long is the brisket smoked, and why does it rest?

Accepted Answer

Our USDA Prime brisket is smoked for 12 to 14 hours, then rests for another 2 to 4 hours. It is delivered to Madison during that resting period, helping the juices, tenderness, and smokehouse flavor stay perfectly intact.

Question 6

Can I order pickup or delivery?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Select Order Now to use the official Pink Heifer ordering page for pickup or delivery when available. DoorDash and Grubhub may also be available, but ordering directly is the preferred way to order from us.

Question 7

Does Pink Heifer offer catering?

Accepted Answer

Yes. We cater office lunches, student organizations, game days, graduations, family gatherings, and special events. Start a request through the catering page or email info@pinkheifer.com with what you are planning.

Question 8

Is Monticello still a full service restaurant?

Accepted Answer

Yes. The Monticello Mothership remains the full service Pink Heifer Saloon and Smokehouse, with its larger menu, bar, live music, events, and banquet spaces. Madison brings the same barbecue standards to State Street in a faster format.

Question 9

Where did Pink Heifer start?

Accepted Answer

Pink Heifer began at the historic Mothership at 149 North Main Street in Monticello, Wisconsin. That is where the recipes, standards, and identity behind the Madison BBQ Saloon were built.

Question 10

What is StageCoach One?

Accepted Answer

StageCoach One is the Pink Heifer food trailer for fairs, festivals, community events, and special gatherings. Ask us about bringing the SmokeShow to your event.

Question 11

How do I join Heifer Herd Rewards?

Accepted Answer

Join free through the Heifer Herd Rewards form. Students can choose Student Herd and show a current student ID in store when a student offer is available.

Join Heifer Herd Rewards.

Join online. Show up hungry.

Choose your membership

Save your member code

Watch for offers

Join Heifer Herd Rewards.

There is room for everyone in the herd.